(27) "The more people think that they are good or identify with good, the more they leave evil alone, and as much as their good increases, unconsciously their evil will increase. We leave it to somebody else. But we have already committed the crime in leaving our evil to other people."

8 May 1935

"To follow the way of delights and passions is the way to the Superman; but it leads to the pale criminal, an inelegant, pale criminal who cannot commit his crime without having an idea of it at which he collapses. That is the pale criminal and as such that term has entered the common speech; one reads it in books and papers, meaning a man who is not on the level of his deed."

I remember a fellow student of mine who was an exceedingly gifted man, but the first thing I noticed about him was that, in reading Nietzsche, the chapter over which he fell down was "The Pale Criminal." It was all the time on his mind and he never got away from it, "What a wonderful chapter—that a man should sacrifice his life even for his crime!" He identified with the pale criminal, and the result was that later on he became insane too—not of course because he had read Nietzsche, but because he himself was doomed to become insane. He never succeeded in life because he was altogether too pathological. But as a student, everybody expected him to have a rather remarkable career: he began in a more or less grand style. Soon he made himself impossible, however, because his delights and passions carried him too far.

He lost sight of humanity and developed paranoia, which is the idea of persecution, the idea that everybody hates one, the reality being that one runs away from people.

But in the sound part of such a man there is still the yearning for connection with humanity, and those ideas of persecution develop as a compensation for the fact of running away from them. All those people who feel persecuted and unrelated are suffering from a minor form of paranoia: to feel observed, to have the feeling of awkwardness and to be géné(embarrassed) in society, but unable to give themselves because they are inhibited by other people. This is the mildest form of it. Such people don't love others. As a matter of fact they hate them and they try to avoid them, and if that thing grows upon them, they will develop ideas of persecution.

Now, the fact that Nietzsche, after the chapter about "Delights and Passions," arrives at the chapter or the stage of "The Pale Criminal" is not abnormal in itself, but perfectly normal; for if one follows the path of passion one will surely come to the place where one's passion becomes abnormal, asocial or criminal, and that is a quality which is in everybody. Therefore, one says, principiis obsta, resist delights and passions, resist in the beginning before it is too late, don't have passions, it is not good taste, it is bad form. The deeper reason is that if one slips too far into such flames, one is sure to land in criminality. But how can you live and have no passion—for then you would escape suffering?"

"Nobody can escape suffering, and to try to escape passion is to try to escape suffering. But as you cannot escape suffering you cannot escape passion; you will suffer from passion either directly or indirectly, and it is much better to suffer directly because indirect suffering has no merit. It is exactly as if nothing has happened. So the indirect suffering in a neurosis has no moral merit. Years lost in neurosis are just lost, without gain."


When he judged himself—that was his supreme moment; let not the exalted one relapse again into his low estate!


"You see, in doing his deed, in committing his crime, he made himself a criminal, and that is what he meant to do because he was a criminal; he was meant to be a criminal. Thus far that is perfectly sound, provided that he knows what he does. But there is the difficulty. If he is a criminal without knowing it, simply doing his deed like an animal, he has absolutely no chance of redemption; but if he knows what he does, there is a possibility, for he is then simply fulfilling his role.

For instance, a good man will do a good deed. He will be forced to be good and feel utterly miserable if he isn't; so there is no merit in it. He is just doing what he is, all quite natural, like an animal. It is very good of the bees to make the honey we eat, one might say, and when they sting us it is very bad, but in either case they have done it unconsciously and there is no merit in it.

But if the man knows he is doing a good thing just because he cannot do otherwise, then there is merit because he is then conscious of that saying of wisdom: The king shall play the role of the king, the beggar the role of the beggar, and the thief the role of the thief, being conscious of the gods. This means being conscious of their role, of Karma, the necessity that the one must play the role of the king because he is born a king, and the other the role of the beggar because he is born a beggar, and if another man is born the villain of the play, he needs must be that villain. Yet if he knows that this is all from the gods, there must be redemption.

That is Hindu philosophy, which simply shows that the condition of redemption is in being conscious of what you do. And from that point of view it is just as bad to be good without knowing it as to be bad without knowing it: neither way has merit; the only chance for redemption is in consciousness, for that is the point where one differs from what one does, where one differs from being a mere animal. So it is a sublime moment here. He should not fall below it by judging himself, provided he knows what he is doing.


There is no salvation for him who thus suffereth from himself, unless it be a speedy death.


"The murderer wants to see blood, as if he knew that committing murder meant his own death. He is seeking to end his existence because—as the text afterwards says—he is nothing but a mass of diseases, a coil of wild serpents which can only wind up in its own destruction. So the Pale Criminal is in that respect the symbol for the man who must end his existence because he is no good—in order to make room for the Superman. That was the point which caught my fellow student, but at the same time he was identified with the Superman, like Nietzsche. He was always talking about committing suicide. He felt that if it were necessary in order to make room for the Superman, he would do so without hesitation. He played with such ideas; he removed himself. So he committed a moral suicide, becoming so much a Superman that he could no longer deal with ordinary mortals and the result was that fear of persecution."

"To think of the moral side, that we should improve the criminal, is nonsense. That is all trash, having nothing to do with justice. It is just to put the criminal to death because we are in his crime too; everyone of us contains a criminal who wants to commit crimes though we don't know it. Our criminal is terribly disappointed. In sleepless nights he complains that we don't give him a chance. Then we read in the paper about somebody who has committed murder and we think, "What an insolent devil! He has smashed a man's head. He can do what I wanted to do, having taken the liberty to commit that crime."

"Only a few fools believe that we are growing better and better every day, hoping that we are improved by improving a few criminals. We are not improved by it and we shall not improve the criminals. That is a bad mistake, because the murderer has murdered himself already long before we cut his head off.

Well, the good admonitions and good counsel here are not very important. The only thing which is relevant would be that sentence, "Let your sorrow be love to the Superman: thus will ye justify your own survival." He obviously means that our guiding or leading idea should be the Superman, and the criminal who is a mass of disease, etc., ought to be done away with, to make room for him."

"Nietzsche doesn't look at the problem from the standpoint of individuation. To him, the criminal is a man who has gone astray, say a fool or a diseased individual who ought to be done away with, so there is no question of consciousness of crime or of the problem of individuation in the criminal. He doesn't even mention it."

"They kill murderers in France, in Italy, in England, in America, in Germany, and in most Catholic cantons of Switzerland; only a few very enlightened and reasonable communities have gone astray so far as not to kill murderers. I am not speaking of our Christianity—that point of view is not valid at all, only talk; I go by facts, and the fact is that capital punishment is valid in nearly all the most enlightened and civilized countries, and I am not against it. There is a very good reason why it is so. All other ways of punishment are wrong.

By putting the criminal to death, one shares the crime; otherwise, one doesn't see the criminal in oneself. One must see one's criminal point: if one does not, one has not shared the criminal impetus, the criminal personality in oneself. And then one never becomes integrated. The purpose of individuation is that every part of the individual must be integrated, also the criminal part; otherwise, it is left by itself and works evil. So thus far Nietzsche is giving recognition to the criminal instincts. For instance, the "red judge" is his own moral function naturally, which might call his criminal instinct by all sorts of bad names: he might say this is perhaps a foolish or pathological tendency. It is, but it is not to be judged from a moral point of view because that is not helpful. It does not help to say a thing is bad or good.

To say it is bad helps least the thing which is the most important, namely, that one can accept the bad thing. You see, when we accept it there is a chance that something can change, but we never accept it. We can improve only when we accept what is part of ourselves. Then we can change, not before."

"Nietzsche says that it is a general prejudice that one commits a murder for a certain purpose, in order to rob for instance, but that it is really madness, that the murder has been committed for the sake of the blood. This is of course an unconscious truth. Consciously, each murderer considers his murder as a by-product."

"Nietzsche asks what the criminal is, after all. He is a mass of diseases, a coil of serpents. For such an individual is terribly pained and tortured really and therefore he commits a crime; nobody causes pain to another person unless he himself suffers pain. As a rule only such people torture or hurt who are hurt or tortured themselves; they want to relieve themselves from their own suffering by hurting somebody else, in order to feel that the pain is not inside themselves alone.

You see, it is as if we were secretly threatened by the invisible presence of the criminal in ourselves, and then we wish that somebody might commit a crime so that we can say, "Ah thank heaven, there is the criminal, there is the evil."

That explains somewhat why we love detective stories and the long reports of crimes in the newspapers; it is of the greatest interest to us to know where the evil is. We exclaim, "What an awful fellow!" We lap it up because we have hunger and thirst for such things; they fascinate us because we have an unsatisfied criminal instinct in ourselves. So the whole respectable community grows more and more uncanny; if nothing happens, everybody looks at everybody else with fear and hate.

Are you the one who is going to relieve us? Am I the one to relieve the others? Am I the one who will set the ball rolling? Am I the one to kill? And then suddenly the news comes: somebody has committed murder. "Thank heaven!"

r/CarlGustavJung - (25) The more people think that they are good or identify with good, the more they leave evil alone, and as much as their good increases, unconsciously their evil will increase. We leave it to somebody else. But we have already committed the crime in leaving our evil to other…

You see, a murderer is a sort of scapegoat for the community; it is as if each community should have a Bouc émissaire(scapegoat) who was burdened with the sins of the community."

"The criminal has a certain social role—this is not my idea, it was valid long before I lived—and therefore a real criminal has always been given the dignity of a sort of ritual in recognition of his merit; first a long trial with judges in wigs and gowns, and then the procession to the guillotine or the gallows with tambours and soldiers and a great crowd, and then he is executed."

"The more people think that they are good or identify with good, the more they leave evil alone, and as much as their good increases, unconsciously their evil will increase. So we leave it to somebody else. But we have already committed the crime in leaving our evil to other people, and we are not even grateful that they spare us."

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

No comments:

Post a Comment