15 May 1935
Part 1
"Nietzsche made one considerable mistake which of course would not be generally considered a mistake. But I call it a mistake that he ever published Zarathustra. That is a book which ought not to be published; it should be reserved for people who have undergone a very careful training in the psychology of the unconscious. Only then, having given evidence of not being overthrown by what the unconscious occasionally says, should people have access to the book.
For in Zarathustra we have to deal with a partial revelation of the unconscious. It is full of inspiration, of the immediate manifestation of the unconscious, and therefore should be read with due preparation, with due knowledge of the style and the intentions of the unconscious. If a man reads Zarathustra unprepared, with all the naive presuppositions of our actual civilization, he must necessarily draw wrong conclusions as to the meaning of the "Superman," "the Blond Beast," "the Pale Criminal," and so on.
And such people will surely draw such conclusions as murder-for-the-sake-of-the-cause. Many suicides have felt themselves justified by Zarathustra—as any damned nonsense can be justified by Zarathustra. So it is generally assumed that Nietzsche is at the bottom of a whole host of evils on account of his immoral teaching, while as a matter of fact, Nietzsche himself and his teaching are exceedingly moral, but only to people who really understand how to read it."
"You have believed hitherto that you were a sort of pious lamb with no particular ambition; then through certain experiences or through the benevolent teaching of analysis you become aware that you really have a will-to-power, and are not that pious lamb you were supposed to be."
"You cannot lift up something from the unconscious without being just a bit lowered in consciousness; that thing has a certain weight. You see, you are floating like a ship or a bowl on that level above, but if you put a load into the ship, it goes down a little and then it remains at the slightly lower level. Of course reason would say, "Is it not nice and reasonable that he admits that he is not quite a saint?"
You appreciate the person for admitting that he is not hundred percent pure gold. But you don't take into account that if the confession is real, that person is no longer floating on the white fleecy clouds of innocence but is a bit pulled down; inasmuch as the repressed content has come up, the person has gone down.
Yet, he really believes that he has added to his whiteness by confessing his blackness—as most people believe—and then he naturally thinks, "I am better than ever before. I am quite different. I am such a nice lamb, and we love each other and there is no sin any more."
"The higher up you are, the more you lose your body, the more you lose yourself, the more unreal you become; and finally you are just a sort of smoke floating in the sky, and that is no human existence. So you are forced to overcome your unconscious, to make these things conscious; but inasmuch as you make them conscious your ship comes down further, and if you become acquainted with the collective unconscious, you are pulled even further under. You may still be laboring under the impression that you can lift something up to consciousness and that the level of your consciousness will not be affected, that on the contrary, it will be increased, improved—but that is an illusion."
"Nietzsche is no longer concerned with a personal unconscious; that chapter about the Pale Criminal clearly shows it. He is here concerned with the evil of mankind, with universal humanity as it is represented in himself, and therefore one can say he is concerned with the collective unconscious; the Pale Criminal is a form in the collective unconscious, the criminal is everybody.
Now, inasmuch as he is concerned with that, he undergoes naturally the dangers of those who deal with such matters. But he labors under the assumption that he is on top, that he has a reasonable consciousness, that he can make it visible and understandable."
"On the conscious level, everybody knows what a criminal is; if you don't know, you take an encyclopedia and look up the chapter about crime, or any handbooks of laws, and they show you. But from the level below, the criminal is something quite different, no longer a statistical or social or juristic phenomenon, nothing reasonable or rational, but a psychological concept.
Therefore, it is already a symbolic concept; it is a concept of the twilight, in the region of the pénombre where things have two sides, the sun side and the moon side. The leading principle above is the sun, and below it is the moon; and whatever is between is in two lights, the light of the sun and the light of the moon. So when someone speaks of crime or the criminal on the lower level, he is conscious of crime from such an aspect; it is a twilight concept, and only people who have experienced the shadow can really understand what he is talking about.
"Nietzsche, in trying to bring something up from this level, could say he had certain tendencies that were discernible: he might steal, he might lie, or even commit a crime. That is more or less understandable on the upper level, as I said. He might say it was his particular psychology, or write a confession like St. Augustine or Rousseau, freely confessing what a sinner he was. Then people would be agreeably shocked: "How marvelous that people can do such things! "—they themselves of course being not concerned at all. That would be possible: you can speak on this level as a personal confession. But Nietzsche is no longer talking from the level of his personal unconscious; he talks of the crime of man, and then everybody is in it."
Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.
No comments:
Post a Comment