(26) "Primitive conditions are all right as long as the conditions are primitive, but the unfortunate thing is that man is not only an animal—in a way he is an animal and in a way he is not—because he has the faculty of developing consciousness."

13 March 1935

"Somewhere our unconscious becomes material, because the body is the living unit, and our conscious and our unconscious are embedded in it: they contact the body. Somewhere there is a place where the two ends meet and become interlocked. And that is the place where one cannot say whether it is matter, or what one calls "psyche." Now everything that can be represented to the conscious is psychological, but if a thing cannot be made conscious, or can only be expressed by vague analogies or hints, it is so dark that one doesn't know whether it has to do with the top or the bottom of the system, whether it leads into the body or into the air."

"Science is the highest power of man, for we can do just what we can do, and when we try to deal with things which are beyond our comprehension, we are overstepping our competence. You see, there are plenty of secrets—only a few fools, morbid intellects, think we have solved all the riddles; anybody with even the smallest amount of imagination knows that the world is a great enigma, and psychology is one of the foremost enigmas."

"Then Mrs. Baumann says: "I don't understand how Christ was crucified by his virtues." That picture of Christ being crucified by his own virtues was an idea which they already understood in the twelfth or thirteenth century, and which you easily could understand in the text of Zarathustra which we have just dealt with, so that by naming your virtues you create the collision between virtues. If you follow up the divergent virtues, if you are just and compassionate and several other things besides, inasmuch as you name these qualities you will be torn asunder."

"Only inasmuch as you are unconscious of your value can you remain together. If you become conscious of your virtues you are lost; you will quite certainly get into a hellish conflict. That people don't get into these conflicts more comes from the fact that they are altogether unconscious; they don't notice it, and at a certain place they stop."

"Nietzsche's idea is that you should not name your virtue; otherwise you will get into a conflict of the virtues and destroy yourself. And at the end of the chapter he says, "And therefore shalt thou love thy virtues—for thou wilt succumb by them." The most foolish thing one can do is to name the virtue, because as long as you don't, you are one, acting under the influence of something incomprehensible and indescribable. You have no wrong impressions, don't know yourself, are more or less a primitive; or more like an animal that is always at one with itself and so never hesitates. It goes to its own death because dying belongs to life; and primitives die with no particular fuss. They take it as part of life. This is in a way an ideal condition, so why try to give names to things? Just because we must: our growing intellect, consciousness, forces us to do so; if we don't discriminate, we are cursed by the primitive condition.

Primitive conditions are all right as long as the conditions are primitive, but the unfortunate thing is that man is not only an animal—in a way he is an animal and in a way he is not—because he has the faculty of developing consciousness.

His consciousness wants to develop; he must give names even to his virtues, and so he is meant for conflict. He can­ not escape it, cannot remain at one with himself. He will get into hot water in the end if he develops at all; and if he has once given a name he must continue to give names. Already, the primitive man has begun to give names, and the more "adult" he becomes, the more he will do so. So it was a particular stunt of old sages to know the names of things: it was understood to be a particular sign of power; to know the names of demons meant power over the demons. But there is a high price on knowing names; you will be tempted, even forced, to give names, but you will pay for it with conflict. Because you have discriminated between things, they begin to compete with each other; and you will be the victim of your own conflict, be crucified, get into the condition of the Christian mystery of self-destruction, self-sacrifice.

In the making of the Superman, Nietzsche is simply continuing in the path of Christianity, developing our hitherto valid form of Christianity into a philosophy that reaches a bit beyond. He tells us to be reasonable, continue the way on which we have begun, name our virtues and be damned for it; if we are damned that is our destruction, yes, but thus we shall give birth to a new man, a man with a new consciousness; a new light will dawn on mankind if we are able to give birth to the Superman. That is his message, and for that it is necessary that he even kill God. He means also that since you cannot avoid giving names, give as many and as accurate names as you know how, because all that works for your own undoing. In the end you are dissolved in conflict, you will be dissociated, disintegrated, extended on the cross, and torn asunder."

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

No comments:

Post a Comment