12 December 1934
Prof. Reichstein:
"We can bring forward the extraverted side, which emphasizes those qualities of old men growing out of experiences accumulated over a long period of time. Old men play a special role as judges, lawgivers, regulators generally, teachers, guardians of tradition, masters, sometimes also as rulers. The old man has steadiness, is less inclined to lose himself in his surroundings. One sees this in individuals as well as in whole nations. The primitive, for instance, loses himself and degenerates in foreign surroundings far sooner than a representative of an old civilization.
The old man possesses an introverted side also: he is the one who has the secret knowledge. He knows the goal, in that he stands nearer to death, to the secret side of the world, the invisible. The near relationship between spirit and death is very far-reaching. The old man is therefore also magician, sorcerer, medicine man, doctor, priest, and initiator. He can become the embodiment of the supernatural or the deputy of a God or Demon."
"The primitive form of religion is magic. To the primitive, the mysterious life force, "mana," is more important than purely physical force, and the chief aim of religious practices is the preservation and increase of life force."
"Among very primitive peoples the spirits do not appear in personal forms, but quite undifferentiated; they are material, but invisible. They are the force that makes things live. The primitive is to a high degree under the spell of this mysterious force. He lives in constant fear of it and never knows when a trap may be set for him by a secret enemy against whom the best counter-magic is impotent."
"It is very significant whether someone imagines that first there was chaos, or first the light, or whether this world was created by Jahveh as the Jews believe, or by the devil as was believed in Iran."
In a new world-period all female things are separated from the male. Poimandres teaches that he who recognizes himself will attain salvation, that is, he who recognizes the primal man in himself. But he who is seduced by love and is content with the body wanders confused in darkness, suffering the fate of death in the sensual world."
"A striking feature of this piece is the complete helplessness of the imprisoned people—not only is a way shown to them, but they must be literally pulled out of their predicament."
Dr. Jung:
"The wise old man and the complicated or dangerous situation belong together; one could say that when man is in a difficult situation, there is a chance of this archetype appearing. He hardly ever comes just out of the blue, but only in a moment when he is really needed. Then you also noticed that it was in particular periods in real history that a man who embodied this image made himself noticeable. When would that be?
Prof. Reichstein:
In a time of disorientation, when there was no great living symbol; in the beginning of our era for instance, and in the Middle Ages at the time of the Reformation. Perhaps also at the time of the Egyptian Thoth.
Dr.Jung:
Yes, but we are too little informed about the history of the Egyptian mind to know under what conditions Thoth came to the foreground; that figure extends over a period of three to four thousand years. You mentioned another example, however, where we can observe how a religion originated: the calling and enlightenment of Zarathustra would be an instance. Of course we also know very little of those days, but we can gather from his teaching that he appeared when the religion of the time had degenerated into ordinary vulgar black magic, such as Taoism became in China. In recent years there has been revival of Taoism in China, but it had deteriorated previously into sort of street magic-soothsayers, and astrologers who made horoscopes, even the oracles of the I Ching were cast in the streets.
The priests were mere jugglers, and the classical Taoist philosophy was practically gone. Zarathustra encountered such a condition in Persia, and his teaching had chiefly the purpose of destroying that luxuriant weed of superstition and popular magic. Religions have always had the tendency to degenerate into those low magic rites and customs, like the Catholicism of the 15th century, when they made money out of the grace of heaven. This was a most disturbing fact to the people who still had some idea of a decent religion, and was indirectly the cause of the German Reformation.
They broke loose from the church which had declined so far as to sell the grace of heaven; it was a sort of regeneration brought about through the degeneration which had existed before. So even in the time of Zarathustra, about the ninth century B.C., we can observe that archetype.
"The mere fact that it is so easy and almost normal to identify with an archetype is clearly shown by Nietzsche's Zarathustra. It is obvious that Nietzsche is identical with Zarathustra because he takes him as a sort of poetical figure, a creation of his own mind;
It is just the peculiar thing about an archetype that you have the feeling of having produced it, yet the archetype is always self existing and you are simply the victim of the illusion that you have made it. That is the disastrous thing which leads us astray. So it is of the highest importance, practically, to learn that there are things in our minds which are not of our own make."
"I have observed in numbers of my own dreams most absurd facts which I could not place anywhere in my life, and a few weeks later they happened in reality. From that I learned that one has intuitions about things which are really outside of our selves and we simply imagine that we are responsible for them. It is the same with that wise old man or with any archetype;
"Anempfindung, that word cannot be translated; it means creating a situation in which you make believe, as if you yourself belonged to it. For example, suppose you build an antique house. Of course, you must have central heating, but it is hidden behind marble work of some kind, and you wear an antique toga and recline at the table when you eat, although what you eat is cooked on an electric cooking range, and you feel exactly like Plato or any one of those old sinners. That is Anempfindung. There are any number of examples.
If you know something of the life of the poet Maeterlinck, you get it—an old monastery, madonnas, moonlight nights—you feel very medieval. Now, that becomes inevitable when the original experience is lost, when the pupils don't experience what the master has experienced. They ought to know really in order to make circles. So this "Thou art I and I am thou" is a magic invocation to force the Logos, or whatever name is applied to the old wise man, to come down and admit the one who is praying to him to be raised to his social status.
But the original experience, becoming aware of the objective presence of the archetype, is just the reverse. Nietzsche's poem proves that originally he had the experience of Zarathustra as being different, split off even from himself, so that he could not say, "Thou art I." He could only say: "You are Zarathustra and I am Professor Nietzsche." But then there was no Mr. Zarathustra living anywhere near Maloja in the Engadine, nor was he in Basel. Nietzsche was not true to his original experience; he had no pistis, no loyalty, no confidence in it. He said to himself that it was hardly possible that Zarathustra should be a reality who really had separated himself from him."
"If Nietzsche had been true to his original experience, he would have understood that Zarathustra was somebody else with a life of his own, a separate being.
Of course, one does not know it but other people can see it.
Well now, if that fact is accepted, then naturally an intercourse begins between man and the personified archetype, from which it be comes finally obvious that that archetype is in a peculiar way man, as man is an archetype; that is, a widening out of consciousness comes about in which the archetype is included.
"The wise old man is also a personification of the self. But the self is still more powerful because it is not only inclusive of the wise old man but of that young stupid fool, man: the self contains both."
"The wise old man is always a personification of God. That is why we represent God with a long white beard sitting upon a golden throne."
"Thoth for instance, is the anticipation of the Logos, so he is also the anticipation of Christ inasmuch as Christ is the Logos. Now peculiarly enough, the temple of Thoth is called the house of the net—the fisherman's net—and the Babylonian Marduk is the Logos and his attribute is also the net. Then the Pope, as the head of the church, is the living impersonation of the Logos, the church being the body of Christ. He is in the place of Peter who is the representative of Christ, endowed with the apostolic blessing, the grace or the mana that has emanated from the Lord himself. And the Pope's attribute is the fisher ring upon which is carved the miraculous draft of fishes with the nets.
You see, the Logos worked like a net which gathered in mankind like a swarm of fishes; the power of the word, a concept, an idea, a point of view, is really like a net. It constellates, it brings together, it unites. You learn once that two things are the same and they will remain the same forever. This is the creative power of the mind.
So this Logos quality of the old man puts him right in loco dei, as Christ is the visible face of God; he is in a way like the Old Testament conception of the Angel of the Face. In Islamic mysticism the Sufi god is the same idea; Chidr, the green one, is the visible element or god. My Somali headman explained to me that Chidr is the first angel of God, meaning the visibility of Allah who is without form, without appearance, without quality. But Chidr is visible; his mind can be seen as man can be seen, as light can be seen or a blade of grass. He has shape. The old wise man, then, is a sort of visible god because he is the word of god—the word that became flesh. You see, according to our biblical ideas, God is sitting on his throne surrounded by his angels, with his orchestra playing on harps and trumpets and so on, and he has a long beard exactly like the old fellow in this book.
And it is a curious fact that the same figure occurs in an entirely different book, Les Tableaux des Riches lnventions. This book was published in Paris in 1600, a reproduction of a much older one, but the frontispiece dates from about 1589. And here is a German book of 1588, printed in Basel, in which there is the same figure, of course with certain variations.
This shows that there must have been a tradition—there were typical symbols. In both, you find the lion with its paws cut off, for instance. We don't know where they originated, but one thing seems to be certain: there is hardly a trace of these symbols before the 15th century. As a rule, they date from the time of the Reformation.
And that great need simply came from the fact that, until that moment, everybody had had the great advantage of confession and absolution; then, that suddenly became obsolete, and instantly people discovered an impossible moral conflict from which there was no redemption, no absolution. Nobody told them that they were absolved—they were never absolved—and that created an intolerable tension. Therefore, the old man came and told them they should make images in order to solve their problems by the priesthood within. The whole church became introverted, and the institution of the church became introverted, and that brought about these series of pictures.
We have such picture-series again in our days because we also are confronted with moral problems which we cannot solve, which are impossible—much worse than those in the year 1500. But, of course, their problems were as bad to them as ours are to us in the present time."
Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.
No comments:
Post a Comment