(19.1) "There has always been a tendency to project the suffering into a divine figure. Why is that so? Why can't one accept it as obviously one's own?"

23 January 1935

Part 1

"Prof Jung: In the Old Testament the idea is that the creator is perfect and creates a perfect world, and the only regrettable and damnable thing is that man makes a mistake. Of course, one could ask why man was made in such a way that he made the mistake, for which a clock-maker has made a bad clock, the clock is not held responsible. Now where does that idea of imperfection come from?

Prof Fierz: It is Gnostic.

Prof Jung: Yes, specifically Gnostic, though I don't know whether Nietzsche ever studied Gnosticism or whether it is his own invention. The demiurgos was by no means a universal god, but a sort of sub-god, a secondary god, an angel or demon who in his vanity created a world."

Footer: Nietzsche would have known little of the Gnostics, but much of Plato. This notion of the demiurgos draws heavily on Plato's Timaeus, which was very influential throughout the Middle Ages. For Plato, this creator-god, the artificer, is clearly below the level of the eternal Ideas. In Gnosticism, the serpent symbolizes mind, which is the means by which the first humans were freed from the dominion of the Creative Power, who had required of man ignorance of good and evil.

"Prof Jung: His neurosis began really when he was a very young man; I think he was about twenty-four when he became a professor at Basel and he soon became neurotic. So it is quite possible that he had not read about Gnosticism, particularly because it was then in ill repute. He would have asked his friend Professor Overbeck, a professor of religion, who would most certainly have told him that it was only imagination, unsound thinking, and all that. And then, you see, he came to the conclusion that that image of God—the kind of theology which claims the metaphysical existence of a God—was all man's work and man's madness. He cut the whole thing down."

"Darwin became known then, and he was most horribly shocking to late Christianity and caused many people to lose their faith. I remember that time very well, and know how Darwin's views were received in my set; it was whispered that there was a dreadful person who said that man came from the monkeys; and it was quite particularly awful because the scientists seemed to back him up. It was the age of materialism, and though Nietzsche's philosophy is of course not a banal materialism, he understood that it was necessary to have that kind ofcritique.

The time was not ripe for a psychological conception of the deity; either a thing was real or it was not. Anything so subtle as analytical psychology was beyond the mind of those times. So for Nietzsche the dilemma was: if there is a god, he must have a metaphysical existence as concrete as this table, or he does not exist. And he came to the conclusion that he did not, though that conclusion was less rigorous than is usually supposed—we will find a passage later where Nietzsche leaves a door open."

A man was he, and only a poor fragment of a man and ego. Out of mine own ashes and glow it came unto me, that phantom. And verily, it came not unto me from the beyond!

"The ashes and embers would be that poor piece of humanity. It is Nietzsche the man himself who has undergone a passionate conflagration, and he projected this experience into a metaphysical suffering God. In other words, he made the attempt not to accept that suffering as his own."

"One could say it was a sort of resignation, in that he assumes it is God's suffering, and is incapable of accepting the truth that it is his own. That is the reason why there have always been suffering gods, not only at the beginning of our era, but long before. Osiris, one of the oldest gods of Egypt, was a suffering God ; they have existed for an eternity, quite apart from the god-kings, who, when they were old or when the crops failed or the cattle died, were put to death because their mana or medicine power had gone wrong. There were many suffering gods in Asia Minor. Christ is only one of them. Prometheus is also a divine sufferer, for instance.

So there has always been a tendency to project the suffering into a divine figure. Why is that so? Why can't one accept it as obviously one's own?

"A creator would say it was his own suffering; but no, he projected it into a metaphysical creator. He was identical and just did not know it."

"For example, if you try to sleep when suffering from toothache or any other painful ailment, you are apt to dream that somebody else is in the same bed and has that toothache; you make a difference between yourself, quite comfortable, and somebody else who suffers. You see, our psychology is easily disintegrated. It disintegrates every night; one part of the system is suffering and another is not, because they are separated from each other. It is quite a usual occurrence that we simply split off the suffering part."

"In war a wound received during action is not noticed; only when there is a lull is it suddenly discovered. In the excitement of the moment it is not felt because the libido is concentrated on something else. This is a general mechanism and it looks as if it underlay Nietzsche's philosophy; his idea that man has created the suffering God is in order to get rid of the acute realization of his own misery."

"We cling naturally to that hero-god, for then we are unconscious of our suffering. It is a fact that one is quite capable of being unconscious of suffering, and particularly can one be unconscious of moral suffering. For instance, you can say your stomach is ailing, but in reality it is a moral situation which you cannot stomach.

Or perhaps you have a pain which you call rheumatism, but if you had that pain in connection with the real cause, if you realized what that so called rheumatism meant, you would undergo a most acutely painful moral or psychological problem. So the more people are in the church, the more they escape psychological suffering—to such an extent that they have no problems when they are good Catholics; and good Protestants can economize a good deal on moral problems by putting their suffering upon the Lord. They say, "It is a very peculiar situation and I don't know what to do, but I don't need to worry; I put everything upon the Lord and hope that he will do his job. I am glad in Jesus, frohlich in Christus; he will take care of it." This is surely very nice as long as it works, but it doesn't work always."

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

No comments:

Post a Comment