20 June 1934
"If people would be a bit more reasonable, with less passion for being very poor or very rich, perhaps things in general would be quieter and better."
"They all say, one ought to, one must, but nobody shows how the thing can be done. There are even people who say it would be quite simple to regulate prices, for in stance; we have ten thousand good propositions but nobody shows the way to carry them out. They say; if only people did so and so, but we have to deal with man as he is, we cannot make a system or a scheme where everybody is doing his duty to the utmost."
"And Nietzsche comes to an end; he doesn't know, for he is the figure that lives in ideas. Now, that is the archetype of the wise old man, who is a system of beautiful ideas. He consists of a tissue of the most marvellous ideas that have ever been visualised, but nowhere is it said how to do it."
"It is quite generally true that our consciousness is chiefly in the foreground—our attempts are chiefly conscious—at least we like to say so. Therefore, we call the person behind our backs our shadow, and the assumption is that no particular heroic attempts will be made by this person. The conscious ego is the one for that. The shadow figure has no body; it is relatively inefficient, and we assume that efficiency, willpower, energy, and all that, are in the conscious."
"Nietzsche's real shadow, that is, the ordinary man in him, was not at all included in the problem."
"If a person is more or less complete, his shadow is visible; if it is not, you feel that person is as if painted flat upon the wall. With more or less shadow, there is more or less negation or contradiction, and without that nobody is complete. People who have only two dimensions are identical with a sort of persona or mask which they carry in front of themselves and behind which they hide. The persona in itself casts no shadow. It is a perfectly clear picture of a personality that is above board, no blame, no spot anywhere; but when you notice that there is no shadow, you know it is a mask and the real person is behind that screen."
"You think you have gone across an abyss but you have merely crossed the stage, you have gone nowhere."
"In the history of a patient who is still embedded in his family, you will see that he usually succeeds in getting members of his family into pairs of opposites, dressing them up to play different roles. The daughter projects into the father and mother, for instance, or the parents into the children. Or in political groups, they even project their problems into the political parties."
People who are still really in the Catholic church have no unconscious. For instance, a book has just appeared, by a Catholic, called Das Dunkle Reich in Uns, The Dark Kingdom in Us, which is about the psychological problem; and the author says that there is no proof of the existence of the unconscious—that there really is no unconscious—it is merely imagination. Of course, almost any man nowadays in his normal senses, as we must assume he is, is simply unable to make such a state ment; but a Catholic can easily, because he really has no unconscious. It is in the church."
"In itself the shadow has no existence; it follows very closely where the body goes, and that is of course the normal condition, as it should be."
"...if the conscious is merely persona-like, painted on the wall as two-dimensional only, then the shadow is set apart and leads a life of its own. This is always the case when one does not realize what one is doing. You know, some people don't realize themselves; they don't know what they are doing. And other people know themselves but they don't know what is happening around them—the two types of course. That is the unconsciousness of the shadow.
The shadow is indispensable for making the whole of a personality;
Nobody is whole without negative qualities. This is lightly said, but in reality it is an enormous problem, looked at from an ethical point of view.
It is so difficult that one knows no other solution practically than to shut one's eyes; if one doesn't look at it, one can live. But the moment one sees it, it is almost impossible, an insupportable conflict. If one takes the moral conflict seriously, it becomes insoluble.
Therefore, people choose the way of the church or something like that, in order to escape the terrible responsibility. There the church steps in with her means of grace, or with the conviction that somebody has dealt with the problem of our sin, or is going to deal with it, so we are relieved of that awful problem. Numerous have been the attempts of man in that direction."
"If the shadow is separated from consciousness, it always has body, reality: it is a spontaneous and active agency.
And inasmuch as the separation of the ego consciousness and the shadow prevents the integration of the whole of the personality—individuation—the shadow also contains the self.
Behind the shadow looms up the self, but then in a negative form. In that case, the shadow has a most destructive power; that is the origin of the demoniacal forces of the shadow. Therefore, it is so important to have the right way with it. For without the integration of the shadow there is no individuation, and no reconciliation of the pairs of opposites, because the shadow is the opposite."
"It is one of the handicaps of the individuation process that the more you are split, the less you have free will, and then the process of individuation is inhibited. First, you must gain a certain amount of freedom, and you only gain that by the assimilation of the shadow. You must learn to deal with the shadow to a certain extent at least, and then proportionately you acquire free will."
"The self is the concept which expresses the totality of conscious and unconscious, and inasmuch as the unconscious is a limitless, indefinable, and irrational concept, the self is necessarily also an only partially rational concept; it covers some thing which cannot be defined fully. You can define the ego, the extent of consciousness, but you cannot define the unconscious, because it is infinite."
You cannot establish a definite borderline which would separate the conscious clearly from everything that is non-ego; you can only say that your consciousness comes to an end here, and there begins the unconscious. But how far the unconscious extends, nobody knows. So the self is an indefinable concept because it covers the whole, the conscious and the unconscious; and inasmuch as the unconscious contains an extraordinary power, the self is an expression of that power.
Therefore, one could say in this case, that inasmuch as the shadow, this terrible jester, is a tremendous problem, he must have a tremendous power.
"One can say that just because we don't realize the destructive powers of the shadow, it appears in a particularly dangerous way. It is so terrible because we are far away and underrate it."
"We increase the size of the ships on the ocean, we increase their means of safety, their speed, and all that, so of course an ordinary storm means nothing; but if there is a catastrophe, which never can be prevented, it is a most horrible one. We try to prevent wars, we make our situation as safe as possible, but of course we create by that the best chance for having a war. We gather a large army and enormous heaps of ammunition to prevent anybody from attacking us, but the other side is doing the same for their own defence, and finally everybody is defending themselves and this means a war with the most wholesale slaughter."
"In the words you speak by chance, the truth is what you just blurt out. We first think the interfering factor has to do with the shadow; we make a slip of the tongue or something else happens to us and we recognize it and say, "Oh well, that was the shadow, it is due to such and such a complex." And we think we can unravel and eradicate it, and then it will stop and not bother us again. But the further we go, the more we see that behind that shadow is a much greater power, and finally we see it is that totality of conscious and unconscious. Then we again think that we have now come to something which is circumscribed, something tangible, within the reach of human reason.
But the self is just as far-reaching as the unconscious; we don't know how far it reaches. We get into an enormous continuity with life in general, not only life in the present; it contains all the ancestral life of the past and intimations of the things to come—all of humanity. So we arrive at a conception of the self which is worldwide, a sort of conglomerate and accumulation of individual minds, and that is simply a conception of a god."
"Every single individual believes in his own absolute importance, in spite of his weaknesses, his dullness, his unimportance; and we forget that through each human being that universal being is working and can produce the most horrible results. We should learn fear again. We suffer from fear in all sorts of phobias, but the reason that so many people suffer from phobias is because their fear is not in the right place. In the Old Testament, the very first principle is the fear of God."
"It has been overcompensated in the New Testament by the idea that God is love and one should not be afraid of him. But God is the one and the other. The New Testament is just a compensation for the terrible truth of the Old Testament that in the beginning was the fear of God. If you arrive at the idea that he is also benevolent, it is a sort of secondary experience."
Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.
No comments:
Post a Comment