(7) "As long as people are unable to realize what individuality is, what the self is, it is projected and there is nothing to be done about it. If it is not projected in Christ it is projected into another leader or a mythological figure, a Buddha or a new religious system."

13 June 1934

"The heart wills the drive towards the destruction of that lame and tame and despicable being called man, the most contemptible of all things to Nietzsche—the thing which should be overcome."

So the will of the heart, that secret will to destruction, forces the head, and no matter what the head may think, it will be forced by the heart which knows that goal. The Superman can only live through the destruction of man as he is. The political analogy to this is the secret will to destruction all over the world, not only in Germany; of course, you see it very clearly there at present, but it is everywhere. Our actual collective unconscious seeks the destruction of millions."

"Nietzsche says here that he loves that will to destruction; therefore he preaches war. That is of course a sort of horrible nightmare to us, but the Eastern attitude would not see so much nightmare in it. They would say, where there are too many people, the number must be lessened, and so naturally a time will come when people will be exterminated to a certain extent: that simply has to be."

(Note: Jung comments on the the relation with the argument between Krishna and Arjuna in the Bhagavad Gita — "When there is increase of unwanted population, a hellish situation is created.")

"Well, you don't need to read it in the Bhagavad Gita. You can hear it in the East from the man in the street who has a natural wis­dom in his veins; he is quite convinced and therefore he has no particular commiseration. You see, we make a hell of a fuss in Europe when several hundred thousand Chinamen are dying of starvation, or drowned by the floods of the Hoang Ho or the Yangtze-Kiang. The Chinamen don't bother so much. They say : Too much folk, they must go. But we Christians have so little faith in life that we think we must preserve every little nuisance that has come into existence.

Of course, it is not nice for the individuals who are actually under the wheel, but, you know, we shall all be under the wheel when those bombs begin to rain down upon our cities. And we ourselves are continuously bringing that about—nobody wants to but everybody is doing it."

"Is it possible to deny that Christianity demands the sacrifice of everything to the one principle, i.e., spirit? And has not analytical psychology shown that the psyche of modern man is in open revolt against this one-sidedness and forces to seek a new way that allows him to live the body as well as the spirit? Is not this the sum and substance of Nietzsche's point of view?

That is, of course, Nietzsche's point of view, but on the other hand we must say that Nietzsche's point of view is exceedingly mysterious to the majority of even highly educated people. They don't understand it. When Zarathustra came out, I was living in Basel and I heard them talking about it, and they were all profoundly bewildered; they had not the faintest idea what it was about. It gave Jakob Burckhardt, the famous historian, a sort of shock. He was frightened by it. And when the rumor got abroad that Nietzsche was in a lunatic asylum, they all said, "Thank heaven!" Then the case was clear: a nightmare was dissolved, and everybody was glad that that man Nietzsche was behind the bars. He had said awful things, but happily enough it was all foolishness, the dream of a madman. Something like that was the mood about fifty years ago, and nowadays it is not very different.

Mankind has not become so much more intelligent in the meantime. Of course, we have had some experiences. The world war helped a great many people to realize what Zarathustra means, or to what it refers at least. But, for the most part, people were happily asleep in the dream of the Middle Ages and had no idea of such problems, as untold millions are still sleeping. They could live just as well in a time when the sun was still revolving round the world. So for such people the whole problem does not exist, and for them Christianity is still the best guide for their lives, no matter how the Christ symbol is understood. You see, it can be understood in many ways, in the Catholic way, in the Greek Orthodox way—there are four hundred Protestant denominations making a fuss about nothing. And then there are all sorts of nonorthodox and nonorganized ideas upon the subject. But the central figure is still Christ.

As long as people are unable to realize what individuality is, what the self is, it is projected and there is nothing to be done about it. If it is not projected in Christ it is projected into another leader or a mythological figure, a Buddha or a new religious system.

And, of course, the number of people who are not conscious of the self, who have not begun to realize that there is such a problem, are countless. Therefore, one has to reckon with the fact of Christianity and to take it quite seriously as the best guide in these matters; for two thousand years, this system has been the best guide for us, as Buddhism has been in India.

As long as people can live in such a system, if it really expresses the facts of the unconscious, then it is good and there is nothing to be said against it; you cannot even criticize it. That means, of course, inasmuch as people are serious and have not simply put an a before their creed—instead of theism, atheism. I should not call atheists serious: they don't see that they are still theists in denying God. I understand by "serious people" those who know that such a thing as a religious experience is possible, and that it means the greatest good one could possibly imagine."

"I am against the destruction of Christianity, because I hold that for thousands of years, the majority of people will not be able to get beyond the Christian conception; therefore, it ought to exist, one cannot abolish it. One should cease the foolishness of thinking that all people are the same and have the same creed. It is absolutely impossible."

"You see, the Self is such a disagreeable thing in a way, so realistic, because it is what you really are, not what you want to be or imagine you ought to be; and that reality is so poor, sometimes dangerous, and even disgusting, that you will quite naturally make every effort not to be yourself."

"One expresses a totality. One cannot individuate without being with other human beings. One cannot individuate on top of Mount Everest or in a cave somewhere where one doesn't see people for seventy years: one only can individuate with or against something or somebody. Being an individual is always a link in a chain; it is not an absolutely detached situation, in itself only, with no connection outside.

"If you can think with concentration, you realize how much you are connected with other human beings, how little you can exist without being related, without responsibilities and duties and the relation of other people to yourself. And all that remains completely in the darkness of participation mystique as long as you don't think of it."

"Inasmuch as we live, we are in the continuum of life. If you think you are separated, it is nothing but a neurotic imagination, and that is of course morbid. But that you are thinking of yourself does not mean that you are morbid. It can be systematic. So if a man feels as the writer does in this case, talking to an audience that does not understand him at all, it means that he is not in touch with his own collective man, or he underrates or overrates something in himself. There is a lack of balance in his judgment.

Later on, Nietzsche explains it by the fact that he has been alone for too long a time, talking to the woods and the brooks and the trees. It is perfectly true that if a man is too much alone, he loses the connection with the collective man in himself and talks about matters which are above the heads of other people; and that is egocentric, too much in his own sphere, so that he does not know the language spoken in collectivity."

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

No comments:

Post a Comment