30 January 1935
Part 2
And this most upright existence, the ego—it speakers of the body, and still implied the body, even when it musth and raveth and fluttered with broken wings.
Always more uprightly learnt it to speak, the ego; and the more it learnt, the more doth it find titles, and honours for the body, and the earth.
A new pride taught me mine ego, and that teach I unto men: no longer to thrust one's head into the sand of celestial things, but to carry it freely, a terrestrial head, which giveth meaning to the earth.
"The body is the truest thing; this is indubitable and undeniable even if it should fabricate poetry and philosophy or other illusions and delusions—the fluttering with broken wings."
"With the collapse of metaphysical convictions, the "I" of man really became important. That was the age of individualism.
You see, the great ego of the world was God and we were nothing but the thoughts of God, and now we find that God is a thought of man. Therefore, man in all his modesty becomes a cosmic factor of the very first order, because he is the maker even of gods."
"Man is forever in the funny position of the religious atheist."
"Nietzsche speaks here according to the prejudice of his time, the materialistic individualism of the eighties: if the ego has everything it wants, everything is all right. Our modern socialistic philosophy is still that; Karl Marx is of that time. It is the enlightened individualism called socialism, the idea being merely that every individual should be granted a decent existence. That is the individualistic ideal sure enough, because if all individuals are not granted a decent existence one doesn't feel well.
If I have no friends with decent homes, I cannot be invited to dine with them, and if I have not a decent home I cannot give them nice dinners. So it is assumed that a certain number of human beings must have nice homes.
Now inasmuch as that formulation of the "I" is a mistake due to the inflation of the ego, at the end of the nineteenth century it began to be overcome."
"The ego consciousness is exceedingly narrow; it contains only a few things in the moment and all the rest is unconscious."
"Your consciousness is so restricted that you must economize, make abstractions; it is really the exact opposite to what people suppose to be the universal consciousness of the deity. One could say that man has come home to himself after travelling in God's consciousness in the cosmos, and finds that the origin of the whole business is the very small and narrow house of the human mind, the narrowness and restriction of consciousness. And he finds that the reason for that restriction is very obviously the body."
"There is the body and the body is in time and space; if it were not, there would not be that restriction of consciousness. Also, if there were no restriction, there would be no consciousness, for if you are conscious of millions of things as it seems to you, you are conscious of nothing: your consciousness is then exceedingly blurred.
So restriction is the very being, the very character, of consciousness. And the reason for that distinctness, that particular capacity of acuteness of consciousness, is the body, which restricts you to a certain place in space and a certain moment in time. It protects you against the elemental quality of cosmic indistinctness.
Without consciousness, how can anything be distinguished, how can anything happen? There can be no world if nobody is aware of it. If there is nobody to speak of the existence of a world there is none. And how can there be an acute consciousness without the restriction of the body?"
A new will teach I unto men: to choose that path which man hath followed blindly, and to approve of it—and no longer to slink aside from it, like the sick and perishing!
"This means: Since man—or his ego consciousness—is a living body, his body is ultimate reality. And that is right: it has to go its own path. It is a good path, and any deviation from it is wrong, just morbidity—wrongness in the biological sense."
"If Nietzsche had written nothing else but this sentence, that surely would be true: one could accuse him of it. But it all comes from the fact that he speaks the language of his time. He says "I," the ego consciousness, without clearly examining that concept of the "I." He never asks what the "I" is really, he has no psychological criticism. The moment he began to criticize it psychologically, he would see that the statement "I," or the expression "ego consciousness," is too limited, it is a mistaken concept; it is wrong."
Beyond the sphere of their body and this earth they now fan cied themselves transported, these ungrateful ones. But to what did they owe the convulsion and rapture of their transport? To their body and this earth.
"Of course if you ill-treat the body, it can throw you out of the house entirely, out of your body. It is like ill-treating objects. You know, objects are inanimate things; they lie about heavily, have no legs or wings, and people are often quite impatient with them.
"Because I ill treat them they turn against me and become contradictory in a peculiar way. I say, "Oh, these damned objects, dead things, despicable!" —and instantly they take on life. They begin to behave as if they were animated living things."
Objects really take on dangerous qualities with people who are particularly impatient with them: they jump into your eyes, they bite your legs, they creep onto a chair and stick up a point upon which you sit-such things."
"People who live in the unconscious are like the unconscious; they are also unconscious."
"The more the mentality or the psyche leaves the body to itself, the more the body goes wrong. The two ought to live together. That explains the bad state of health of intuitive people who don't even need to be metaphysical; it is enough that they are a bit too intuitive. They live too much in mere possibilities, and then the digestion begins to suffer, they get chronic diseases, ulcers of the stomach or the duodenum, for instance. Or they may get other disturbances of the body of an infectious nature; many organic diseases are due to this peculiar lack of attention. People who have lived too much upon spiritual ideas should bring their attention back to their bodies. So one can say it is always a wise thing when you discover a new metaphysical truth, or find an answer to a metaphysical problem, to try it out for a month or so, whether it upsets your stomach or not; if it does, you can always be sure it is wrong. It is necessary to have metaphysical ideas—we cannot do without them—but it is also necessary to submit them very seriously to the test whether they agree with the human being: a good metaphysical idea does not spoil one's stomach."
"The body is merely the visibility of the soul, the psyche; and the soul is the psychological experience of the body. So it is really one and the same thing. Therefore, a good truth must be true for the whole system, not only for half of it."
"Something might apparently be quite nice for the body, but it is very bad for the experience of the soul, and in that case I have a metaphysical enteritis."
"When life flows, then I can say it is probably all right, but if I get upset I know something must be wrong, out of order at least. Therefore, people with one-sided convictions of a decidedly spiritual nature are forced by the body to pay attention to it."
Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.
No comments:
Post a Comment