(13) "It is a possession when people preach things which they don't make true in their lives. They simply run away with a disembodied spirit who talks marvelous high stuff, but they are not confronted with it in their lives. It never becomes a problem."

7 November 1934

"If the archetype of the wise old man appears, then naturally the ego is just caught—one is always caught by unconscious contents. Then you find yourself in a peculiar alienated condition; you see things and say things and feel things as you wouldn't before."

"I say to a man: you must make a difference between yourself and your anima, between yourself and all that is contained, thought, or felt through her influence and emotionality. To a woman I say: you must make a difference between yourself and the flow of thoughts which goes through your head: don't assume that things are so because you think so; or don't assume that other people think like that because that thought is in yourself. Criticize it and see whether it is your own. When a bad animus case produces a marvelous opinion, I say: "Now come! is that yourself? Do you really back up this thought? Are you convinced that things are like that?" "When I come to think of it, no!" "Then why the devil should you talk like that? Whose opinion is it?" Then perhaps she finds out that her father has said it or any other authority; or she has read it in the newspaper. And so Nietzsche preaches any amount about the body, but ask the man Nietzsche what he thinks about the body and he will tell a different story.

It is a possession when people preach things which they don't make true in their lives. They simply run away with a disembodied spirit who talks marvelous high stuff, but they are not confronted with it in their lives. It never becomes a problem. They never even think of making it true, but simply accept it as a fact and behave entirely differently. I complain that they talk and think in one way and behave in an­ other, but people are even quite proud that they can think differently from the way they feel. They don't see that this is a split which goes through the whole condition, and that it is a morbid condition, a lack of wholeness, a lack of integrity."


This had Zarathustra said to his heart when the sun stood at noon-tide. Then he looked inquiringly aloft,—for he heard above him the sharp call of a bird. And behold! An eagle swept through the air in wide circles, and on it hung a serpent, not like a prey, but like a friend: for it kept itself coiled round the eagle's neck. "They are mine animals," said Zarathustra, and rejoiced in his heart.

 

"As Till Eulenspiegel laughed like mad when he went uphill, and wept when he went downhill. People could not understand it, for wisdom is never under­ stood by ordinary people, but to him it was perfectly clear. In going up he thinks of the descent and that makes him laugh. He rejoices in the idea that soon he will be able to go downhill. But when he goes down­ hill he foresees that he will soon have to climb again and he weeps therefor. And that is the nature of Zarathustra. So it is the man Nietzsche who discovers that he is at the noon of life. He was born in 1844 so he was just thirty-nine when he started to write Zarathustra, and that is the noontide, the beginning of the afternoon."

"Zarathustra sees those two animals together, representing pairs of opposites, because spirit is always supposed to be the irreconcilable opponent of the chthonic, eternally fighting against the earth according to the dogmatic idea and the idea of old philosophies in general. For, wherever you go in the world, if you compare the highest philosophical views of a certain period, say two thousand years ago, you find that nearly everywhere people came to the same conclusion: namely, that matter is low and bad, and spirit is good and beautiful and high—and that matter ought to be subjugated by spirit, and not the reverse."

"There are many eaglelike birds, in fact, that are the typical enemies of snakes. So the snake is in a very precarious situation and Mrs. Baumann is quite right when she points out that it is really the image of Nietzsche's own predicament. He is just lifted out of the ground, and as a material man, as a man of the earth, he is in the power of that enormous bird. The eagle is the archetype, you see; the wise old man is the wise old bird. The Hamsa, the swan, has lifted him up."

"The snake might have a fantasy and squeeze his neck so that he couldn't breathe, which would be very bad for both; it is most risky, it could go wrong in many ways. That is substantiated by the subsequent remarks of Zarathustra, namely:


More dangerous have I found it among men than among animals; in dangerous paths goeth Zarathustra. 


He finds his peril in the wrong place; he is afraid of the perils amongst men. Of course there are relatively small perils among men; the perils among beasts, particularly one's own beasts, are much greater. But he feels the danger-tension manifested in this peculiar symbolism. Now, as Mrs. Baumann has also pointed out, the serpent is here represented as a friend of the eagle, and that would be explained from the personal side as a demonstration of the fact that the relation between Nietzsche and Zarathustra is a friendly one.

He doesn't feel as if he were the victim of Zarathustra; he feels the claws of the eagle as a loving gesture, so one could say that the serpent, by free will, encoils or embraces the neck of the eagle. This would indicate that it is not at all a hostile situation, but a union, a reconciliation obviously. The fact remains, however, that the snake is carried up into the air, away from its usual abode, and this would be the man Nietzsche carried off his feet by the Hamsa, the bird of the archetype, and he doesn't defend himself against it."

"The man Nietzsche counts precious little to the archetype. He just happens to be the tool. But the man is of course in an awful situation. He is possessed, and he cannot defend himself, for he doesn't even know that he is possessed, and that is a wonderful opportunity for the unconscious. Inasmuch as everyone has instincts, the archetype of the old man is not the whole unconscious. It is only one of the many inhabitants, and therefore there are other helpful spirits or powers about, which will appear. So if a man is possessed and does not know it, he will have perhaps a dream which tells him something, or something will be shown to him which elucidates the situa­ tion.

To a man like Nietzsche, for instance, a dream will appear which contains this image of the eagle and the snake. If such a case should happen in reality, I would explain it in this way: the light of heaven, the eagle, the divine word has caught you; naturally, how could you resist? So you gave yourself to it. But you must know that it is exceedingly dangerous; we don't know how it will turn out in the future. I should say it was a precarious situation for that serpent—probably less for the eagle, because the serpent is chiefly under the illusion of friendship."

"It is most probable, therefore, that the eagle would take the serpent for a ride in the air; it is a concession, as Nietzsche's life itself was a concession. There is little difference between Nietzsche's life and the life of a saint; he forsook his ordinary life, and went into the woods. The woods were called Rapallo, the Engadine, Nice, and so on, but he was alone, a hermit. He lived entirely in his books. He devoted himself to spiritual practices, one could say, and he lost the connection with the world of the flesh. He really became a sort of modern saint; the spiritual side caught hold of him more than was good for the solution of his moral problem.

For to solve the problem one must give equal value. We cannot say the side of the spirit is twice as good as the other side; we must bring the pairs of opposites together in an altogether different way, where the rights of the body are just as much recognized as the rights of the spirit."

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

No comments:

Post a Comment