(12) "It is not left to God alone to fight the devil, or, as the Persian religion expressed it, it is not left to the light alone to fight the darkness. Man enters the battlefield: one could say as the living god, as the manifestation of god in the flesh."

31 October 1934

"People ordinarily think that a right thought must be throughout, not realizing that it is only a very small noise in the attic, and the rest of the house is as it always was, nothing having happened at all. The head, the brain is only a small part of the body. It is just an illusion when you think the right thought in your head means a reality; it is a reality as far as a thought reality reaches; the thought itself is real, but it has not become a reality in space. It has not been expressed by the whole of you. So Zarathustra has the right idea no doubt: he includes the body in the process of individuation, and he emphasizes it because without the body there would be only a disincarnated spirit. But inasmuch as Zarathustra himself is a thought-being—he is really just an archetypal spirit who has the right idea—it is not the man Nietzsche.

Nietzsche is not the Superman, but he identifies with Zarathustra naively because he is so swallowed up by that archetype from the collective unconscious. He intuited it because it is a figure of such mighty attraction; his whole life was sucked in by it and the body could go by the board. That special body, the man Nietzsche, simply disappeared behind it. Therefore, there is nobody left to receive Zarathustra's message. Zarathustra speaks his own message, using the means of the body of Nietzsche, and the ordinary human being Nietzsche does not exist. He could not stand up against Zarathustra; he was completely dissolved."

"Nowhere in Zarathustra can you find a place where Nietzsche really appears; he is nowhere among the audience. He is the preacher, but he does not listen at the same time."

"Inasmuch as Nietzsche is identical with Zarathustra, of course nobody could possibly be a personal friend to him; nobody can deal with such an identification because it means an inflation. One cannot form a personal relation with a person who has an inflation; anybody with an inflation is neurotic, and it is absolutely impossible to form a relation with a neurotic, because one never knows with whom one is dealing. A neurotic is always a yea and a nay."

"Transformation of the collective unconscious into the collective consciousness is what one calls revelation, and any revelation that really comes from the collective unconscious is like a megaphone because it is a message spoken to many; it reaches a crowd because it expresses a collective thought. So inasmuch as Zarathustra has expressed the collective thought, he has become part of the collective consciousness."

"It can be quite aside from the individuality. It is often as if Nietzsche did not exist, or did not know what he was saying. Therefore, many revelations take place through completely unconscious individuals; they speak through a trance. It is even the primitive assumption that a revelation always takes place through an unconscious body, in a sort of trance. Suddenly a spirit seizes the person and he becomes unconscious or gets into a state of ekstasis and utters the revelation. He speaks the divine word, and afterwards can remember nothing of it. It is even a criterion of the revelation from the collective unconscious, that the individual is put out completely while it is happening; the typical medicine-man often behaves like that."

"Individuation is impossible as long as one is split into pairs of opposites. They must be overcome; how, of course, is the great question, but it must be done from a standpoint which is beyond good and evil. Nietzsche himself felt that symbolically when he wrote an important part of Zarathustra in Sils Maria, "six thousand feet beyond good and evil." He felt raised to the seat of the gods, above all the conflicts of the low plains where the herd dwells. From that height he was able to unite the pairs of opposites, to be free of doubt, to create a standpoint which is the reverse of old Zarathustra's moral conflict."

"Nobody becomes conscious of himself without the conflict: we need the conflict. As long as we are not living according to our own choice we cannot know of ourselves. We must be able to choose for ourselves."

"It is not left to God alone to fight the devil, or, as the Persian religion expressed it, it is not left to the light alone to fight the darkness. Man enters the battlefield: one could say as the living god, as the manifestation of god in the flesh."

"If you discover what you call a truth, you should test it, try to eat it. If it feeds you it is good, but if you cannot live by it and only assume it ought to feed other people, then it is bad. The real test is that your truth should be good for yourself. Not one dog is coming to sniff at it if it doesn't feed yourself. If you are not satisfied with it, if you cannot enjoy it for twenty, fifty years, or a whole lifetime, it is no good. If you are hungry, if you think your companions must be redeemed, and that they must be grateful to you on top of all, then you make a mistake: you may know the idea is no good. So don't play the missionary."


"Behold, the good and just! Whom do the hate most? Him who breaketh up their tables of values, the breaker, the law-breaker: he, however, is the creator."

 

"But he is the destroyer! No good breaking the tables of values, they are weak enough already; you had better hold that little bit of value together. They need no particular wildness because they will break up all by themselves and altogether too early; we know from history that values begin to break up long before there are new ones to take their place. Therefore, we always go through a time of destruction when people are without orientation and without laws. Usually only the greatest misery forces people to create new laws and new values. If Zarathustra were not so impatient, the man Nietzsche could follow him. He could give Zarathustra the right rhythm, prevent him from being too impatient. Then he would not talk of breaking the tables of values. They could be preserved a little longer. They are weak enough: they will break up without our help."

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

No comments:

Post a Comment