5 June 1935
"This tree standeth lonely here on the hills; it hath grown up high above man and beast. And if it wanted to speak, it would have none who could understand it: so high hath it grown. Now it waiteth and waiteth,—for what doth it wait? It dwelleth too close to the seat of the clouds; it waiteth perhaps for the first lightning?"
"The Bush souls of primitives are thought to inhabit certain animals with whom they are then related. If the tiger contains a man's Bush soul then that man is the brother of the tiger—or the python, or the crocodile; and the Bush soul, under a different aspect, lives in certain plants or stones or rivers, and then he is the brother of that river or whatever it is. All that simply means the recognition that a part of the human psyche is essentially not human. It is naturally not what primitives assume it to be, but is a fact which we would call a projection—and we no longer know that projection, we are unconscious of it."
"Bush soul phenomenon is a sort of point de repere, primitives always have such things—like a shrine or the churinga of the Central Australian aborigines for instance—and inasmuch as it does function, they assume rightly that it is filled with life, that it contains soul."
"So our point of view concerning the tree is that Nietzsche has a Bush soul which is identical with the archetype of the wise old man, and this chapter should inform him of the fact that the wise old man is not human, but is also of the nature of the tree, and one therefore cannot identify with him."
A man possessed by the anima is just a piece of something that you can no longer talk to. And when a woman identifies with the animus without thinking, she identifies with the Bush soul, and then she is not quite human and loses human contact. Any decent discussion ceases instantly when the anima or animus enters the game.
Now Zarathustra, inasmuch as he is not identical with Nietzsche, realizes here his own nature. This chapter is like a dream in which Nietzsche, the dreamer, is informed that Zarathustra is a tree and if he only could understand that, he would no longer identify and all these absurdities would come to an end—his conflict would come to an end."
"People who are not exposed to storms are never in need of wisdom."
"If you are wise, you will have a wide surface and be well connected with the earth; then you are reasonably protected against the danger of the lightning. Not always though. So, as Mr. Allemann rightly remarked, it is a condition, an assault or an immediate explosion in which one is suddenly overwhelmed by the collective unconscious; to call it inspiration is pretty mild: it doesn't fully describe the danger of such an event."
When Zarathustra had said this, the youth called out with violent gestures: "Yea, Zarathustra, thou speakest the truth. My destruction I longed for, when I desired to be on the height, and thou art the lightning for which I waited! Lo! what have I been since thou hast appeared amongst us? It is mine envy of thee that hath destroyed me!"—Thus spake the youth, and wept bitterly. Zarathustra, however, put his arm about him, and led the youth away with him. — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ
"This paragraph corroborates what we have been saying. The young man identified himself with Zarathustra. Zarathustra was the temptation for him, he strove to be like him; and then Zarathustra became his danger: the archetype broke in upon him."
"The archetype in itself does not mean invasion and destruction; it is eternally quiet unless it becomes constellated, stirred up by the misbehavior of man. If a man leaves too many things to the unconscious and so gets into a tight corner, the archetype begins to stir as if in compensation.
And then if he thinks what a devil of a fellow he is to have such a good idea, well, there he is! He is identifying with the source of his idea and becomes too big. The lightning has struck him and he is done for. You see the youth says, "It is mine envy of thee that hath destroyed me!" That is very clear: he wanted to be like Zarathustra but Zarathustra did not allow him to remain normal; the young man did not realize what a terrible danger he was incurring by identifying with an archetype."
"The whole mental revolution in Germany is chiefly an activity of the Puer Aeternus, but there the wise old man is absent.
Nietzsche's Zarathustra was an attempt to foresee and to compensate for the danger that his country would fall a victim to the Puer Aeternus, the boy. That same problem is in Goetz's Das Reich ohne Raum, the kingdom within—of course it has nothing to do with the Christian kingdom of heaven—where there is a revolution of boys. Nietzsche had so much foresight that he tried to compensate the coming events by a book of wisdom, but of course it was in vain. You see, the only possibility by which a Puer revolution can be avoided is the anima; without the anima it becomes unavoidable."
( Jung's large and nationally diverse clientele convinced him that there are cultural influences on the form a neurosis takes: thus, France seemed to produce more men who identify with man's feminine side, while Germany ran more to those who remain boys. )
And when they had walked a while together, Zarathustra began to speak thus: "It rendeth my heart. Better than thy words express it, thine eyes tell me all thy danger." — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ
Here Zarathustra very clearly realizes the situation. He admits that he is having the same conflict as the young man; Zarathustra' heart is torn too: he knows what it means to the young man to be pulled up to the heights and not to be at one with himself. For Zarathustra is also not at one with himself inasmuch as he is Nietzsche.
The Alpha and Omega of all the trouble with Nietzsche is of course that he is all the time identical with his figures, never separated from them.
He has no psychological critique whatever and so he cannot give them their true value; he cannot conceive of a psychological existence that is not himself, not his consciousness. But that is all a consequence of his time. If he had been more modern, if he had had psychologial critique, he would have said, "This spirit of Zarathustra is a tree spirit, but a spirit that takes me up to heaven and then lets me fall again is surely not myself: it is an elemental power to which I have fallen a victim."
"As yet thou art not free; thou still seekest freedom. Too unslept hath thy seeking made thee, and too wakeful. On the open height wouldst thou be; for the stars thirsteth thy soul. But thy bad impulses also thirst for freedom." — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ
"Here, one could say, the whole tragedy of Zarathustra begins. That young man is striving to identify with Zarathustra, to be a dweller on the heights and to be free from the fetters of the earth, but if he escapes the law of the earth he becomes an inhuman spirit: he will be struck by lightning and destroyed. Now why does he want that freedom? And freedom from what? Well, very obviously, as Zarathustra says, there are evil instincts below, the wild dogs."
"Thy wild dogs want liberty; they bark for joy in their cellar when thy spirit endeavoureth to open all prison doors." — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ
"If he contains wild dogs, evil instincts in his system, he is partially a wild dog and he should not try to escape from his own dog-likeness, he should remain there in his kennel. If he escapes the body, he will decay; he simply escapes life if he escapes the kennel. Now, it is most important that Zarathustra so gladly assumes that the thing down below in the valley must be a kennel full of wild dogs, for that is by no means certain. It might be horses and asses and cows, quite lovely things, perhaps some pigs too, and the whole makes a perfectly workable farm, exceedingly useful and also quite nice.
Why just wild dogs? Why such a hysterical statement? What kind of psychology does such an assumption imply?"
"It is late Christian psychology, or ordinary Protestant psychology—there is his father. To him the body is of course evil; one does not even look at it, but simply assumes it is wild dogs. But even if that were true, these dogs are a part of nature like wolves. Of course they are not just agreeable—there are nice animals and animals that are not so nice—but in themselves they are all right; wolves occasionally eat human beings if they are very hungry, but we also eat animals, and by the million, so we have absolutely no ground for blaming those animals for eating a man occasionally.
So there is no reason why we should revile our instincts. They are just the ordinary appetites, just as bad and just as nice as the instincts of all nature. It is that particular moralistic Protestantism which reviles instincts and makes them unacceptable; they get evil because we put the devil into them. We say they are devils and cannot be touched, and naturally they will be bad be cause we send them to hell.
Nature is neither good nor bad, and if we judge nature by our foolish categories, it is as if we put it into a dirty drawer which would make even pure nature dirty."
"We cannot do away with the living man by making him spirit—he must live here—and we must really assume that inasmuch as there is life it makes sense, and that life is not properly lived when we deny half of life."
Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.
No comments:
Post a Comment