20 February 1935
Part 2
Behind thy thoughts and feelings, my brother, there is a mighty lord, an unknown sage—it is called Self; it dwelleth in thy body, it is thy body.
"And here he explains it and here he falls down because you cannot say it is this or that, it is always neti-neti. But he knows it is the body and that is the mistake; if he identifies the body with the self, he brings the self into the body or the body up into the self, and that produces an inflation of the body. It is a most curious fact that Nietzsche, an intuitive, should overestimate the body to such an extent. Of course, the body is extraordinarily important but that is an overrating."
"The difference we make between the psyche and the body is artificial. It is done for the sake of a better understanding. In reality, there is nothing but a living body. That is the fact; and psyche is as much a living body as body is living psyche: it is just the same."
There is more sagacity in thy body than in thy best wisdom. And who then knoweth why the body requireth just thy best wisdom?
Thy Self laugheth at thine ego, and its proud prancings. "What are these prancings and flights of thought unto me?" it saith to itself. "
A by-way to my purpose. I am the leading-string of the ego, and the prompter of its notions. The Self saith unto the ego: "Feel pain!" And thereupon it suffereth, and thinketh how it may put an end thereto—and for that very purpose it is meant to think.
The Self saith unto the ego: "Feel pleasure!" Thereupon it rejoiceth, and thinketh how it may ofttimes rejoice—and for that very purpose it is meant to think. To the despisers of the body will I speak a word.
That they despise is caused by their esteem. What is it that created esteeming and despising and worth and will? The creating Self created for itself esteeming and despising, it created for itself joy and woe. The creating body created for itself spirit, as a hand to its will.
"What he says about the self here is absolutely to the point; the self even creates esteem and contempt for itself. That is an understanding which is typical of the East; it is not Western.
Nietzsche, and there Nietzsche is very great; he draws from very deep sources. In the East they knew it long ago; so to them the love of God and the hatred of God are essentially the same. And rightly so, for if it only matters that you are concerned with a thing, then it does not matter whether you are concerned by hatred or by love. Therefore, they have the saying that if a man loves God he needs seven incarnations in order to reach him, but when he hates him he only needs three. As a rule we are really far more concerned when we hate than when we love, and in that Eastern saying one recognizes this kind of psychology. So it does not matter to the self whether you love or despise; it is only important that you are concerned.
But here again Nietzsche makes the one-sided identification of the self with the body, and of course that is not satisfactory; he endows the body with a creative faculty or a meaningful faculty, which, even with a tremendous effort of imagination, cannot be put into it."
Even in your folly and despising ye each serve your Self, ye despisers of the body. I tell you, your very Self wanteth to die, and turneth away from life.
No longer can your Self do that which it desireth most:—create beyond itself. That is what it desireth most; that is all its fervour.
But it is now too late to do so:—so your Self wisheth to succumb, ye despisers of the body.
Miss Hannah: "If the ego won't live as the self wants it to, live its life completely, then the self usually does seem to want to die. I mean, if it cannot get an individual to accept the individual problem or task, it is then as if it wills death—as if by killing, it would get a chance to try again."
. . .
Prof. Jung: "When we deny an important part of ourselves the right to existence, when something is continuously, for many years, repressed and macerated, then that thing always takes its revenge in the form of a suicidal wish. For, every form of split in ourselves after a while becomes personified.
If you find in a certain respect you are stupid, you hate it and try to avoid all those occasions where the stupidity could come to the foreground, because you know you will make a stupid ass of yourself. And if it appears in spite of yourself, you say, "Excuse me, there my stupid ass came out again. I am an ass in a certain respect and it has gotten the better of me." That is personification. Then you have a stable in which you keep your ass, but you live upstairs and are a respectable gentleman. We have done that with the body; we put it into the stable, feeding it very poorly—at least we say so. But by mistake, in a marvellous way, it has been fed time and again. If anybody catches you in the act, when you are down in the stable with fodder for the ass, you say, "I beg your pardon. I have such a weakness. I am sorry and I will repent." And then you go to church and fast and repent that you have fed the ass. Now, that of course is not proper; it is not very helpful to the mental and physical development of the ass. But the lower self is happily enough a greedy animal which you cannot always hinder from feeding; if it is not done legitimately, then illegitimately."
"The more we pay attention to our psyche, however, the more we are aware of the things that happen, and we know unfortunately for what purpose they were done. So the body becomes a moral problem with us. What about the ass in the stable? It is no real way to leave the stable door open. That cannot work in the future; we must buy a meadow where we can feed the ass in a legitimate way. It must be acknowledged that there is such a thing. For if we don't acknowledge it, then with an increasing amount of morality, of consciousness, we find very efficient means of locking the stable door, and then the ass dies, naturally. If we don't let him live, he prefers to die. And then we develop a suicidal wish.
Of course, with our power to keep things locked up and concealed we don't realize that it is a suicidal wish. It may begin with an upset of the stomach, or continuous constipation, or you are terribly tired, or cannot walk. Probably it is already a lack of will to live, the beginning of the suicidal wish; most of the neuroses have that character. In agoraphobia, you don't dare to cross the street, or you may be afraid of a big crowd of people, or afraid of being fenced in: that is all the suicidal tendency. It means that your will to live only goes so far.
It does not risk itself in crowds, in the open spaces of life. You are already partially lame and you seek a situation in which you can fall down, a threshold over which you can stumble, or a car that will run over you; people have little accidents which are simply preparatory for a great catastrophe, where they get into an avalanche or something of the sort.
Now, Nietzsche explains that it is the self, really, that doesn't want to live, because one thus deprives the self of its own experiment. Let us assume for the sake of argument that there is such a thing as the self, that living potentiality which accounts for the existence of our spirit as well as our body—both being essentially the same. Sure enough, our ego-will is not identical with the self-will; our self-will does not want what the ego wants. Why has the self created the body? I don't know why we are not wind; we might be forms made of air and beyond sex or appetites or digestion and such nuisances, but it is a fact that we have bodies which have been created by the self, so we must assume that the self really means us to live in the body, to live that experiment, live our lives. And the ego should not choose whether we are to live this or that; we must have a different criterion. I don't doubt that certain things are meant not to be lived, but we must find out what they are. Contradictory taboos and laws are not given by the ego, nor by an assembly of egos, nor by the church or the whole state; those are only police regulations—including our morality, which is also a police regulation.
But there is one law which is much more severe and much more accurate than any other, and that is the law of the self.
So you must inquire what experiment the self wants to make. Everything that disturbs that experiment must be avoided and everything that helps must be lived, and you will see the consequences on the spot. If you do something which disturbs the experiment you will be punished, much more severely than in a police court. And if you do something which rather serves your experiment, you will have the blessing of heaven and the angels will come to dance with you. You are helped along. You have ungodly health, and you develop powers which you have not had before because you have obeyed, not the ego, but that will of the self. Mind you, it is not the ego that wants to make that experiment. Often the ego says, "For God's sake I only hope that this thing is not coming to me!" If you have a fundamental dread somewhere, you can be sure just that is the experiment of the self. You see, the body is meant to live; it has to be served, and your self has a very particular purpose with it, presumably. Of course, nobody can say what the individual experiment is; for one it is this and for another that, and it is for nobody alike. It is an entirely individual question. Inasmuch as we are individuals our experiment is individual, and the point of life is that this particular individual should fulfil itself."
"For it makes no point in life to create a crowd of beings who try not to be themselves."
"Now, if the experiment is denied to the self, the self is fed up after a while and says, "Well, the experiment is not worthwhile, I prefer to disappear." As its purpose has been thwarted or starved, so you will be starved of life; your libido just steals away and leaves you high and dry, ... you are left as a mere wall decoration, two dimensional, flat, casting no shadow. Then you are a mere husk of yourself; the real life has gone because the experiment has been denied to the self. And then it is just as Nietzsche says, the self wants to perish—no use to continue that experiment."
"According to Eastern philosophy, the experiment can be repeated innumerable times—all the more the more it has failed. But the ambition of the East is to reach such a condition that the experiment does not need a repetition—that it is final, all questions answered."
"The experiment is not made in order to let something run down. It is a question and you look for an answer. That you look for the end and do not resist the end, that you live with the certainty of the end, is obviously the way life wants to be lived. Then it is properly lived, because you are accepting the conclusion at the end of the experiment; and that is right, it is healthy. If you live with continuous resistances against what might come to you, of course you are simply resisting the execution of your own experiment. So the idea that death is a goal, that it is the inevitable conclusion of your experiment, also comes in here. And it fits in with Nietzsche's profound optimism that you must say "Yes" to the eternal return of things. He puts it that way: he says you must have the courage to repeat; you must love life to such an extent that you can even say, "Once more!"
To succumb—so wisheth your Self; and therefore have ye become despisers of the body. For ye can no longer create beyond yourselves. And therefore are ye now angry with life and with the earth. And unconscious envy is in the sidelong look of your contempt.
"Here a bit of the unconscious comes in. You see Nietzsche au fond(basically) already knew of the unconscious; he was aware of the shadow, and that is of course the deepest reason for what he is."
"You see the mistake he makes is that he identifies the self with the body. And here the self wants to destroy the body. That is the tragedy of the rope-dancer and the buffoon at the beginning of Zarathustra; the rope-dancer, Nietzsche the man, is overrun, cast away: he is no good.
That Nietzsche identifies the self with the body is of course illogical, for you then come necessarily to the conclusion that if the body died, therefore the self wants to die. That is his conclusion. But if you take the self in the way I propose, it is of course somewhat different. I don't identify the self with the body. Then the body is just one of the experiments in the visibility of the self(for Jung the self is represented as both spirit and body), and then you can say, "If that thing won't function, it will be cast away; it is no good." You can see how these things really happen in human life."
"Life wants to get at its result and if you don't chime in, then you are cast out like nothing at all, as if you never had been. And then the experiment is made again."
Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.
No comments:
Post a Comment