(15) "Civilization is nothing but a widening out or intensification of consciousness, and the fate of increasing consciousness is threatening everybody."

21 November 1934

"There can be no consciousness without continuity. If continuity is lost, consciousness is practically valueless; it is a mere representation of the moment. Without the continuity of memory, there are no means of comparison and therefore no possibility of judgment. That may be seen in people who have so-called progressive amnesis, where the memory fades so that there is no recollection of anything farther back than a few days."

(Jung mentions a dream of Enkidu in the Epic of Gilgamesh, where an eagle takes Enkidu into the iron claws, and is flown upwards for four hours.)

"You see, here we have that symbolism. The lower inferior man is taken by the iron claws of the spirit-like consciousness which is detached from the ordinary corporeal human being, and is carried up into the air very high, but in the end he is dropped and killed. This is exactly the fate of Zarathustra, or Nietzsche, as you know; this is the rope-dancer who behaves as if he could not fall, as if he were a bird upon the rope, winged, but he is pushed down by an evil spirit that comes upon him and he lands upon the earth crushed."

"Inasmuch as we have still a spinal cord we have a psyche, and it has a certain independence which is usually concretized as the serpent. Then the eagle on the wing is something like a representation of the brain, which is united in the center by that famous commissure consisting of fibres that spread out into the two hemispheres of the brain."

"After Enkidu's death, Gilgamesh feels a horrible loss; you see, he would then be in the position of a man who consists of consciousness only. And that is some­ thing which we feel in our civilization: we suffer very much from the fact that we consist of mind and have lost the body. So suddenly, when he is left by Enkidu, Gilgamesh begins to realize the fear of death. He says: "Now I also, I myself, shall die like Enkidu; my innermost is perturbed by pain, I grow afraid of death, and therefore hasten to the prairies. [He is riding over the prairies on his horse.] I take my way now to the powerful Utnapishtim, the one that has found eternal life, I hasten to reach him.

When I see lions on the prairies in the night, I become fearful; I lift my head and pray to Sin, the moon, and to Nin-Urum, the lady of the castle of life, the luminous one among the gods. To her my prayers are going. Preserve my life unharmed!" You see, he feels instantly the lack of life and grows afraid of death. And that also is very characteristic of our civilization. You will find in studying the psychology of other civilizations that those people are far less afraid of death than we are. They take things in a different way; they don't put so much store on life as we do. To them, life and death are a matter of course; to us, it is awful that there could be such a thing as death. The white man in Europe is afraid of death because he has lost the body­ he has lost his friend Enkidu."

"That is a parallel to Zarathustra, so you can see what an enormous problem Nietzsche dealt with. It is a problem which has extended over thousands of years, the problem of the origin and fate of consciousness, which is absolutely synonymous with civilization, or with the psyche, or with human existence in general. For civilization is nothing but a widening out or intensification of consciousness, and the fate of increasing consciousness is threatening everybody."

"In the introductory section of the Prologue there was a good deal of actual performance, showing how Zarathustra first liberates himself from humanity, and then from his own isolation. He returns to humanity and is then up against his real task.

For then, of course, comes the question: What are you going to say? You know, he talked to the people before as if he could simply tell them, and he made the discovery that you can­ not tell people. Of course, everybody says they want to be told, but if you try, you discover that you are wholly mistaken, for you find no ears, so you must find another way. And then it is as if he found that Christ also could not tell people; only the fishes he miraculously created found their way into the bellies of the people, not his words, so he had to be content with his twelve disciples."

"It is much easier to preach. Therefore, so many people preach in order to escape being. Therefore, we all want to be missionaries. You see, when a missionary goes to Africa he is, as we say, a stag. He has white man's clothes, he has chop-boxes, he has a watch, and so he is a great man, very good and wonderful; and he doesn't need to do anything: he is great from the very beginning."

"It is the cheapest way on earth to fix up feelings of inferiority: when you live among an inferior crowd, you easily can be great. You see, you naturally start with preaching. If you have a good idea, you want to preach it. But then you discover that there are no ears to receive it, and because it seems as if somebody ought to get it, you feel that you must be the person and you apply the same principle to yourself: you begin to preach to yourself. And that is a very useful thing, which I advise every preacher to do. Go and preach Christ to yourself; that is where you should begin—you are the very first. For, the man who wants to preach is one who wants to run away from his own problem by converting other people. "

"In the Catholic church you have the light, the symbol—everything is provided for you—and if that is no longer satisfactory and you go beyond, into what do you step? Of course, you can step into Protestantism, but if you are born in Protestantism, what do you do then? Well, you can step into Buddhism, say, or theosophy, or something of the sort; and if that leaves you dissatisfied, what remains? Nothing but your shadow, all the things you don't like. And because there is nothing else, the darkness that is in you, round you, is the only thing you can see. Everywhere it is dark."

"When you step beyond a given order of things, you are naturally in the utmost freedom, but you are isolated; you can say you are god in your own desert, or that you are a victim. If you are courageous, you say you are the lord of your own desert."

"Nietzsche was not a mean mind or an absolute fool. He was a highly gifted man, and you can see on every page of Zarathustra that his morality is a thousand times sharper than the traditional morality of the pulpit. A thief that is in prison is not less a thief because he cannot steal; let him be the cashier of a great bank and see what happens. If he doesn't steal then you can say he is probably not a thief. So "thou-shalt" is a sort of prison where people hold to a certain rule, but are always thinking: "If I were rid of that rule I would do God knows what!" They never know what they would do if they were free. There is no morality, no moral decision, without freedom. There is only morality when you can choose, and you cannot choose if you are forced."

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

No comments:

Post a Comment